A few weeks ago, I had the creamiest potato soup for lunch. I went home the next day and re-created it, and I think my own version was even creamier.
Yes, I realize this makes multiple posts this week that include bacon. I just can’t help it. Bacon is my soulmate. It never leaves my side. It doesn’t judge me.
However, I think it’s time bacon and I took the next step in our relationship. I’m going to start doing squats with bacon and bacon bicep curls. It’s very necessary.
If you don’t like bacon or don’t eat it, it definitely isn’t necessary in this soup.
(And if you are one of those vegetarians/vegans that reads my blog, thank you and I love you! It can be bacon overload sometimes.)
I added the bacon once the soup was finished – half of the bacon went into the soup, the other half was saved for garnish.
The starchy potatoes gave the soup such a thick, smooth consistency. It was addicting.
I don’t make soup very often, because, well. . .I have no patience.
While soup is simmering away, I usually consume a few bananas, some sandwiches, chocolate chips by the cup-full, and, of course, wine, since it most often lands in my soups.
No wine went into this soup, but I had a few sips for good measure.
The best part of this soup was that while it was super-duper creamy, there were some soft chunks of potato in it, too. I used yukon gold potatoes and left the skins on – such a tasty treat!
Baked Potato Soup
Serves 6
6-8 large yukon gold potatoes, baked with skin on and chopped
2 tablespoons butter
2 tablespoons flour
1 cup heavy cream
2 cups skim milk
1/2 cup chicken stock, if needed
1 cup grated smoked cheddar cheese
2 green onions, chopped
4 slices bacon, fried and crumbled
Heat a large pot on medium heat. Once hot, add butter and flour, and whisk into a roux. Add heavy cream, potatoes and skim milk, continuously stirring until thickened. Stir in cheese, making sure it doesn’t stick to the bottom. Simmer for about 15-20 minutes. Depending on desired consistency, add chicken stock. Stir in 2 slices of crumbled bacon and green onions. Season with salt and pepper if needed.
Serve and garnish with remaining bacon.
I went back for 2nd’s, 3rd’s and 4th’s – the soup was that incredible. I actually ate it all before Mr. How Sweet got any of it.
Oops.







I’m Jessica and this is where I share my stuff. You will find a balance of healthy recipes, comfort food and indulgent desserts.
Wow, that is creamy:) We have a 10 pound bag of potatoes, they were on sale, I couldn’t help myself. This soup recipe will come in handy:)
Reply
I’m going to make this soup today! I don’t even like soup in general, but the pictures on your blog make me reconsider everything.
I’m amazed at all of the beautiful recipes you create. Great work!
Reply
I’m a Southern girl. Bacon is my friend :)
Reply
Ooohhhhh myyy goodness!! That looks FANTASTIC. I don’t think i’ve ever tried legit potato soup before but this looks AMAZING. I want to try it. I don’t think there’s any heavy cream in this house..would using all skim milk work?
Reply
Jessica — February 12th, 2010 @ 9:19 am
Cassie-
Using just skim milk may not make it as creamy, but you can definitely try! If you have 2% or a thicker milk, it may work better, too. You could also just add some flour gradually until it gets thicker. :)
Reply
oh my gosh. this looks amazing and perfectly creamy! there’s nothing wrong with your relationship with bacon, it’s inspiring :)
Reply
Potato soup is 100% my absolute FAVORITE!!!!!
I forgot to tell you… last weekend I went out to dinner and had Peanut Butter Cheesecake with bacon bits inside and an oreo cookie crust. It was so good!
Reply
Well, I don’t eat bacon, but my boyfriend LOVES it! I’ll be trying this little recipe out for him. Maybe V Day dinner?? Looks delicious!
Reply
I love a loaded potato soup – and I LOVE bacon. I think you and I would be great friends :-)
Reply
Love that you left the skins on! And I like the combination of both cream and skim. Good stuff!Hope you and the man have a wonderful Valentine’s Day
Reply
yep…never knew this was made.
Reply
Yum! Yum! Yum! This looks awesome! I am so bad at making homemade soup…I rely too much on the cartons (but hey at least that is one step up from a can, right??)
Reply
I used to always order the loaded baked potato soup from O’Charley’s… not sure if yall have those up there in PA… anyway, I LOVED it so much, but this looks even creamier and yummier!! Thanks for the recipe!! :)
Reply
Gasp! My favorite! This looks incredible – I am the biggest fan of baked potato soup…and the bacon…oh my the bacon. Looks incredible!
Reply
this is great!! such good comfort food for the COLD ness! Have you tried O Charleys loaded tater soup?! UMMM DROOOL! i bet yours is just as good!
Reply
Oh, that looks like heaven…and I do love me some bacon. Yum!!
Reply
yummm when are you moving to nyc to cook for me
Reply
Yuuummm any potato soup reminds me of vichyssoise. That’s my ultimate favorite, especially with some golden leeks and scallions on top!
This is a perfect meal for a cold day!
Reply
I just might have to try this… I have tried a few of your recipes now and this you do a great job with directions and ‘yumm-ability’. You rock.
Reply
Bacon Yum.
Reply
Well I might be mostly vegan, but that looks so good I thin I might need to try a veganified version of this… tempeh bacon, nut milk, earth balance, maybe some pureed raw cashews for richness?? Oh now I really want to try this!
Reply
Mmmm…I LURRRRVE baked potato soup! Yours looks awesome!
Reply
My dad makes the best potato soup EVER and I’ve got to say, yours might give him a run for his money!
Reply
YUM! I have that bowl but in plate form…same design!! love it!!
Reply
I loove huge chunks of potato in soup.
You always make your meat look pretty, so I’m cool with it :)
Reply
ok you are a rockstar. you made it really thick, just the way I love soups. sweet.
Reply
You are killing me with all this bacon, girl!
Reply
Yum! I love a thick soup. Hearty, filling, delicious!
Reply
yum. I love soup, especially potato soup. squats with bacon sound good to me haha
Reply
Looks sooo good (even though I am one of those vegetarians). BUt seriously, those look almost like mashed potatoes!!! AMAZING!
Reply
I don’t normally like potato soups, but your recipe and photos are making me want to make some stat! yum! :)
Reply
very delicious!!
Reply
My husband would move in with you for this one: butter, milk, onions, potatoes. The way to a man’s heart is thru his stomach w/ food like this no doubt!
Happy VDay, Jessica!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)
xoxox
Reply
Oh gosh my sister should come let you cook for her.. that recipe has got her name all over it!!
Reply
This looks just perfect for Blizzard Day Soup! Gorgeous pictures!
Reply
How can anyone not like bacon? I’m not a huge soup fan, b/c they’re usually so runny and bland, but this, b/c it’s creamy, looks worth the effort!
Reply
Dear…that’s not soup. That’s pudding! Look at how thick and creamy it is! YUUUUMMM~
Reply
This looks so delicious and comforting. I think I’m 2 blog posts away from craving bacon! I’ve already given into butter :)
Reply
This looks SO good! I could use nice big bowl of this soup, especially with all the snow around my house!
Reply
I make a very similar version with the exception of frying the bacon first, then making the roux in the bacon fat instead of butter. Nom!
Reply
oh my gosh jessica! your recipes get better every day….seriously! i think i am going to gain 10 lbs by just looking at them…..this will be great during the winter weather we have been having! thanks for another yummy post!
Reply
I love potato soup, but this perfects it! Wow, I have to try this sometime soon. Drooooooooooooooooool :P
Happy Valentine’s Day!
Jenn
Reply
between this and the chicken pasta, I’m totally going to have my bacon fix :)
Reply
Mmmmm,you may be the only blogger who makes me really wish I still ate bacon+ meat. This soup sounds and looks amazing!
Reply
In honor of my undying devotion to your blog…and your AMAZING recipes, I am making a gigantic pot of this today…with lots of extra crispy bacon. Maybe I’ll even make bacon bruschetta (have you noticed how bacon goes well with EVERYTHING?) to serve with it. I <3 you!
Reply
Jessica — January 10th, 2011 @ 1:35 pm
Yum! Enjoy it… I wish I was there to eat it with you!
Reply
Becca H. — January 10th, 2011 @ 7:11 pm
You may not realize it, but you WERE here with me :-)
Potato soup is my go to, make me feel better, warms me when its cold, very best comfort food! Can’t wait to try this recipe!!!!!
Reply
All right… utterly stupid question, but you say to add baked potatoes- Whenever I’ve made soup I’ve put raw potatoes in it, because they always boil in the soup. This soup is different, so how do you suggest baking the potatoes? I know… Stupid question, but I’ve never baked a potato. Bread, cookies, quiche- yes, potatoes, no. How pathetic. Help a girl out!!
Reply
Jessica — February 21st, 2011 @ 3:06 am
Scrub the potatoes, poke lots of holes in them with a fork and bake at 400 degrees for about 30 minutes. :)
Reply
I just wanted to tell you that I think I’m in love with you. My BFF Leah and i send each other your info all the time. Your pictures and creations are fantastic! pizza potatoes….crab stuffed eggplant – this potatoe soup….i’m starving again!!!!!!!!!!!!!
thank you!
Reply
Hi! I was searching for a recipe to make for dinner and knew I had to make this asap with the potato, cheddar cheese, and bacon combo! I just made it now and wanted to let you know I’m loving this soup. I didn’t change anything except I used a higher percent milk (whatever I had in the fridge). Perfect for a chilly night in pajamas! Thank you so much for posting this! =)
Reply
Lorri — March 25th, 2012 @ 8:18 pm
see i was wondering about the milk because i refuse to buy any this other than whole milk. so it turns out right?
Reply
katie — March 25th, 2012 @ 8:28 pm
Yes it came out perfect! The same full, fluffy chowder texture too. I live in Southern Japan and the milk here is about 3% (and I used 1 c whole whipping cream too), but that didn’t affect the soup at all I think. Not the healthiest soup haha, but oh wells it was great and satisfying!
I found this on Pinterest a while back and knew I had to pin it. I love your blog anyway, and I’ve never made anything I didn’t like from your recipes. Anyway, I made this tonight. It was perfect. Thanks for sharing such great recipes!
Reply
The barbell curl specifically targets the biceps brachii which is located on the front part of the arm between the shoulder and the elbow. This muscle’s primary function is elbow flexion and forearm supination. The biceps also has two heads known as the long head and the short head.;;,.
Look at all of the freshest content on our new blog site
<http://www.ideascollection.org
Reply