Cookie Dough Dip Trio [3 New Flavors!]
I have this little flaw, and it’s called impatience.
Okay, it’s a huge flaw. Massive. Enormous.
I attribute this to growing up in the internet generation and getting everything likerightthisverysecond. Admitting you have a problem is the first step, right?
So, last night when I decided to add different ingredients to the original cookie dough dip, I was planning on waiting until later in the week to share. A sweet Christmas present, if you wish. Plus, I have a handful of savory appetizers to share!
Instead of cooking dinner, I belted “I Want a Hippopotamus For Christmas” eight times until I got the perfect, whiny voice. I heard it once on Sunday and it hasn’t left my head since. Then I mixed up the three new flavors of cookie dough dip and ate 16 animal crackers and four spoonfuls of it for dinner.
And grew more impatient by the second, so much so that my finger was pulsating over the publish button at 8:45.
But all good things come to those who wait. Even if it’s only 12 hours.
For instance… peanut butter chocolate chip cookie dough dip.
And double chocolate fudge cookie dough dip.
Even creamy snickerdoodle cookie dough dip. That really tastes like snickerdoodles!
I wish I could pick a favorite. You’d probably get a quicker response out of asking me what my favorite song is.
Except right now it’s that stupid hippopotamus song.
I started by making a normal-sized batch of cookie dough dip, then separated the mixture into three equal parts – going a little heavy-handed on the snickerdoodle dip portion since it wouldn’t have any extras added in like peanut butter or cocoa powder. Each flavor ended up with about three-quarters of a cup of dip.
The snickerdoodle dip actually tastes like snickerdoodle dough. I dubbed it the best dip ever.
But then I tried the peanut butter combination, which literally is exactly like peanut butter cookie dough. Maybe it’s my favorite?
I’m quite indecisive, but it’s with good reason. Here’s a plan: you make all three dips then report back on which is the best. It is a difficult task, but someone has to do it.
Cookie Dough Dip Trio
Instructions
- Start with one batch of cookie dough dip and divide it into three equal parts.
- For Snickerdoodle Dough Dip: add 1/2 tablespoons cinnamon (or 2 tablespoons cinnamon for a full batch)
- For Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip: add 1/4 cup peanut butter and 1/4 cup chocolate chips (or 1/2 cups for a full batch)
- For Dough Chocolate Fudge Dough Dip: add 1/4 cup cocoa powder and 1/4 cup chocolate chips (or 1/2 cups for a full batch)
Did you make this recipe?
Be sure to follow @howsweeteats on instagram and tag #howsweeteats. You can also post a photo of your recipe to our facebook page.
I appreciate you so much!
Now, who’s getting me a hippopotamus for Christmas? I think it’s the only thing that will get this song out of my head.
154 Comments on “Cookie Dough Dip Trio [3 New Flavors!]”
Wow.. this is intense! Love the double chocolate fudge!
Once again, I bow down to you :D
Good lord.. This is heaven. Three cookie dough dips all at once = Lethal!! Great photos by the way!!
I’m going to go ahead and ask the question on everybody’s mind: when do you start posting recipes for cake batter dip?
Excellent idea.
I am pretty sure you are the most evil (read: genius) person ever!
I’ll take that as a compliment. :)
Oh, it is the highest compliment possible!
Genius. GENIUS!
I just gained ten pounds reading this post.
j/k ;) these look amazing Jessica!! I’m with Victoria – bring on the cake batter dip ;)
Pingback: Tweets that mention Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter Chocolate, and Double Chocolate Fudge Cookie Dough Dips | How Sweet It Is -- Topsy.com
You are so flippin’ creative! I so want to try this but I HATE cream cheese… and most creamy things that I could substitute… what else could I use to make it “dippy?”
I realize this was from a month ago, but I just saw the link on another site. I make this same dip and use strained yogurt (often called yogurt cheese) instead of cream cheese. It makes it taste a bit like a cheesecake (more tang) and is very, very good. To make the yogurt cheese just take plain yogurt and strain through a fine coffee filter or cheesecloth. Let the whey drip into a bowl and just let it go overnight in the fridge. The yogurt gets very thick, like cream cheese, but without the cream cheese flavor. Hope that helps!
You’re killin’ me, girl.
I think I am going to be the size of a hippopotamous by Christmas. Don’t be surprised if I show up at your doorstep Christmas morning. :)
You and me both!
well, with these dips i’m going to TURN INTO a hippopotamus for Christmas!
I need to find a reason to make this. It would be far too dangerous in the house by my lonesome. OH!!! NYE party. Done. Now I don’t want baby B to come next week. I must make at least one variation of this for that party. LOL
Yes you must!
I am officially in love with your blog and everything you make! Oh my word 3 cookie dough dips?!!?! They look soooo good. I actually don’t think I could even describe how insanely delicious they look. I LOVE snickerdoodles so I am so trying that one. And of course I want to try the chocolate fudge cookie dough dip. I won’t be able to make the peanut one though (have to go in for peanut allergy testing!!! So bummed about that!). Because the peanut butter cookie dough dip is calling my name.
Thanks so much girl! And what a bummer about the peanut allergy testing.
you have officially outdone yourself… glad i waited to try the dip because now there are 4 versions i want to try!
I think I now have that song stuck in my head. If I’m singing it for the next four days you are SO to blame.
My goodness, I really do want to try all of these!
Where is Mr. How Sweet going to find a hippopotamus with only 4 days until Christmas? Do you know what the costs are going to be to 2 day priority mail said hippopotamus once I find one for sale? Another good question is where would I keep him once I found him? In the garage? You are going to kinda, sorta notice a hippopotamus in our garage.
I think it’s final…I’m making this for Christmas. Absolutely incredible!! :)
I finished all my holiday parties, but I need to find an excuse to make this!
I love Mr. How Sweet’s comment, haha
I am deprived from internet for 2 days, come back with 98 (!!) posts on my Google Reader, and this is the first one there. I think I gasped, out loud.
I love that you just POST what you have, what comes to mind, don’t “hoard” your posts or try to save them up (I may be guilty of trying to save my “good” recipes…but you are breaking me of that, even if you dont know it!…thanks friend!)
Hope you have a good, low stress day!
And the dips, mmmm, good.
And I am reading all your posts with NEW EYES now. STaring at the photography now even more :)
Jess – let’s run away and get married. I don’t even swing that way, but I have a afeeling it could be the best decision of my life.
I’m in.
I don’t blame you for sitting on edge, waiting to hit “Publish.” Once again, this is out-of-control goodness that just must be shared immediately! I was at a holiday party on Saturday night and actually pulled up your original cookie dough dip page to show some of the girls right in the midst of the party–one of the guys asked what the fascination was with the computer when they found us huddled wide-eyed around the screen with pictures of your dip. Good times :)
Wooohooo! So glad the dough dip made convo at the party. :)
It’s odd to me that there is chocolate and peanut butter here but the one that calls out to me the most is snickerdoodle.
I kinda thought the same thing!
holy cow. everyday you outdo yourself! and ps – i sing that song all season long. my mom and i call each other everytime we hear it on the radio. never gets old :)
That is some seriously yummy-looking cookie dough dip right there. I couldn’t pick a favorite either…..of course that doesn’t mean that I won’t make them all and test them out just to be sure.
oh my gosh. You will continue to amaze me with the delicious ideas you come up with. Snickerdoodle Dough Dip? I wish I had this for breakfast!
It would be good on pancakes. :)
I was already planning on making the cookie dough dip on Christmas Eve for our families big party, but now I can make the trio!!!!!!! Wahoooooo!
Everyone is going to love this! Thank you for the wonderful recipes!
Oooh, great idea!! You’re the queen of cookie dough :-)
yay!! I’m making these for new year’s eve! They look awesome. Thanks!! :)
wow, just wow. i’ll definitely be making this for my new year’s eve jam. i feel like a cookies & cream version would be great as well with chopped oreos mixed in!
Um.. how did I not think of that?! Yes it would!
I’m quite indecisive as well, and I think that 3 flavours is highly necessary. These look ahhhmazzing!
You’ve got to stop this! Seriously, my scale has been moving little by little towards higher numbers. And these dips looks like they could break the bank …er… scale ;)
I am incredibly impatient too. That’s why I currently have a giant burn on my finger. I just couldn’t wait for my toast to be finished…
On the other hand, this. looks. epic. Like, amazing, out of control, epic!
Oh wow…not one, not two, but THREE variations on Cookie Dough Dip? They all sound so luscious. The dip was already on my menu for my pre-Christmas drinks gathering, now I’m definitely considering making the trio. Mind you, I’ll look like a hippopotamus after eating these yummies!
I think I just need to make 3 full sized batches of all 3 of these flavors…it’s Christmas time, after all!
I think you do too!
I’ve never heard this song before
You’re not missing much. Take the most annoying song in the world and multiply it by 20.
do you separate the dips before adding the chocolate chips? or does the snickerdoodle dip have chips in it as well? i think I’ll make these for my christmas eve party!
Yes! Separate them then add the certain ingredients according to flavor.
Cookie dough dip? How did I miss this before? And three of them?? Amazing!
The snickerdoodle one is the best because really snickerdoodle cookies are the best! These all look amazing!
True dat!
I want a pottacookie dip for Christmas.
Only a pottacookie dip will do.
Don’t wanna doll, no dinky tinker toy,
I wanna pottacookie dip to eat up and enjoy.
Hahahah. You seriously make my day ALL the time.
SNICKERDOODLE DIP!!!! amazing!!!! Now you can dip vegetables in there!!! :)
Key lime pie dip next!! lime juice and coconut and I will be in heavennn
Working on it!
Drooling. Is this what people mean when they talk about food porn?
I think so.
I love all of these new versions! I still have to try the original, but these are on my list now too. :-)
AH! I had already decided to make the dip for Christmas and now I have to decide which of these to make? I don’t know!!
Make all four!
I bet the base recipe would also be great with a bit of eggnog or molasses for a gingerbread dip!
OH wow… you are SO right!!
YESSSSS!
I can’t stand that song. I love cookie dough.
We are soulmates.
…
God bless you, Jessica. And your crazy penchant for making cookie dough dip.
Oh my. I had a hard enough time keeping myself away from the regular cookie dough dip! I think we all know what Im bringing to Christmas dinner now. :)
These look too good to be true! I would probably eat the entire bowl, which would not be too good to be true though :)