Can you keep a secret?
Last night I went to a karate slash pilates slash bootcamp-ish slash heart attack class. I know. Your face? Your expression you are wearing right now? I was thinking the exact same thing. But my face was red and dripping with beads of sweat.
Anyway. That’s not the secret.
All I could think of during this class was cheese. Cheese on toast, cheese with jam, cheese on nachos, cheese in my face. If you find this peculiar then you really don’t know me. If you are not the least bit surprised, well then… you sure are neat. And I like you.
After flinging myself through the front door following my uncoordinated attempt at unarmed combat and eating four handfuls of peanut butter stuffed pretzels (I hear they are excellent for muscle recovery. write that down.), it dawned on me that peanut butter pretzels do not a dinner make. I had already spent a luscious 30 minutes with a quesadilla earlier in the evening, but when you jump, kick and squeeze your body into oblivion, you deserve a second dinner. It’s like a law or something.
Then I remembered the buffalo chicken mac sitting in the fridge and decided it qualified as a post-workout recovery meal.
Uh… wait a minute.
This is sort of like mac and cheese. Or it is mac and cheese. Can someone tell me what the difference between baked pasta and mac and cheese is? Educate me. It’s probably the cheese to pasta ratio. Copious amounts of cheese make up this buffalo chicken pasta. Maybe baked pasta doesn’t have lots of cheese. I don’t know.
But guess what? Now it does. That’s the beauty of this whole little deal we’ve got going on. I make things and name them whatever the heck I want. Sometimes you call me on it. Other times you look at me with googly eyes. Most times it is still delicious. Except for anything with broccoli. If I ever tell you something with broccoli is delicious, I’m lying.
I don’t care what you call it. Just get on it.
Baked Buffalo Chicken Pasta
serves 4-6
1 pound pasta (I used whole wheat orecchiette)
3 boneless, skinless chicken breasts, cooked and cut into chunks
1 tablespoon butter
1 tablespoon flour
1 1/2 cups milk
4 ounces freshly grated monterey jack cheese (I used half a brick) + more for topping
1/3 cup freshly grated sharp cheddar cheese + more for topping
1/3 cup buffalo wing sauce
1/3 cup panko bread crumbs
salt and pepper to taste
for garnish: 3/4 cup chopped green onions, 1/2 cup fresh cilantro, 1/2 cup gorgonzola cheese, additional buffalo wing sauce
Preheat oven to 375 degrees F.
Prepare water for pasta and cook according to directions.
While pasta is cooking, heat a medium saucepan over medium heat. Add the butter, and once it’s melted and bubbly add the flour. Whisk together to create a roux and cook for 1-2 minutes until mixture gets a bit golden in color. Add milk, stir and turn down heat to low. Continue stirring until milk thickens. Add in grated cheeses and continue to stir until mixture is smooth. Stir in buffalo wing sauce. Taste and season with salt and pepper if needed.
Spray a baking dish (9 x 13 is fine, I used a round 4-inch deep dish) with non-stick spray. Add pasta and chicken, then pour cheese sauce over and mix throughly until everything is coated. Sprinkle with additional grated cheese and bread crumbs. Bake for 25 minutes or until cheese is golden brown. Remove from oven and immediately top with gorgonzola, green onions and cilantro. Drizzle with buffalo wing sauce.
And save me some? I’m still hungry.








I’m Jessica and this is where I share my stuff. You will find a balance of healthy recipes, comfort food and indulgent desserts.
This recipe is great! Great flavor and I used left over chicken so it super easy! Awesome!!
Reply
Trying this tomorrow for dinner…..thanks Sybil:-)
Reply
The difference between mac and cheese and “baked pasta” is that mac and cheese does not have meat in it. The addition of meat technically makes it a casserole. I learned this distinction from watching a video on the food network’s website on the topic a while back.
Reply
Prue — June 6th, 2012 @ 5:07 pm
Was that necessary to leave a comment about?
Reply
Christy — July 6th, 2012 @ 11:02 pm
Agreed.
Nick — July 31st, 2012 @ 8:10 pm
The author explicitly asked someone to distinguish between macaroni and cheese and “baked pasta”, so yes, gene’s comment was necessary.
Great Meal! Had difficulty thickening the milk but it turned out fine anyways and I added a clove of minced garlic into my sauce ! very heavy and can feed probably 8 people.
Reply
Sounds great! I’ll have to try this sometime when it’s my turn to cook dinner for my roommates! What kind of buffalo wing sauce did you use?
Reply
For wings and other ” Buffalo Style” stuff I use only Frank’s ( brand) hot sauce- Just the right blend of hot and flavor – I’ve tried a substitute – but so far nothing comes close – When flavor is more important than heat – Only go with Frank’s – BTW – Franks is brand used by folks credited with creating ” Buffalo Style” chicken wings….. BOL
Reply
Yummy! Easy and delicious!
Reply
We tried this tonight.I was very disappointed.I had a hard time getting the milk to thicken.A lot of work for mac and cheese.My family did eat it and liked it but not enough to make again.
Reply
JESSICA — July 20th, 2012 @ 9:11 pm
Maybe I did something wrong…????Maybe I needed more cheese.
Reply
ES — August 10th, 2012 @ 5:48 pm
I couldn’t get the milk to thicken either. I think the proportions of the recipe are off.
Jill — March 28th, 2013 @ 8:07 pm
The proportions aren’t off, you just need to bring the butter/flour roux and mild to a boil. It will thicken almost immediately. I made this and it was wonderful. Even my 18 month old couldn’t get enough.
I just want to say I love your style of writing… even if it wasn’t a recipe you were talking about I would still want to read what you say because you are funny. :)
Reply
Your not alone cause i am not familaur with any bands haveing to do with sweaters or poneys eaither! I betcha they arent even worth listening to. However this buffalo chicken with pasta and oodles and oodels of cheese is what i’m talkin about… ITS THE BOMB!
Reply
I think your milk did not thicken because there is no mention of adding the flour to the milk. A tablespoon of flour is noted in the ingredients, but is not mentioned in the assembly instructions.
Reply
Jessica — August 24th, 2012 @ 9:03 am
No, it definitely is written in the instructions. Right after the butter melts.
Reply
To all those who said they had trouble getting the milk to thicken, did you let it come to a bubble? Those ratios sounds about right to me, as we’ve used basically the same amounts for mac & cheese, cheese sauce for broccoli, or white sauce for years. But I do know now (thanks to Emeril, LOL) that it a roux won’t reach its full thickening capacity until it comes to a boil. No offense to anyone’s skills, just popped into my head.
Reply
Would the cook time change if I used ramekins?
Reply
I made this last night and it came out perfect! I used 1T butter, 1T flour and only 1 cup of milk to make the roux. I had no trouble getting the milk to thicken although it did take 15-20 mins. I used cheddar, asiago, and tossed in some leftover cream cheese. It was delicious, thanks for the recipe!
Reply
WORST anything I have EVER cooked!!!!!! Followed the recipe exactly and the pasta was so dried out it was crunchy. How embarrassing!!! Will never try your web site again or any of your recipes!!!! Hamburger Helper is better than this! OMG, I cannot stress enough how bad this was. A total waster of ingredients!!!!!
Reply
Daniela — October 30th, 2012 @ 10:44 pm
How hard is it to get the pasta tender? Lol you don’t even need this website to do so, not the recipe’s fault .
Reply
Courtney — November 15th, 2012 @ 2:26 pm
Seriously, I cannot even fathom what you did to your pasta to make it “dried out” and “crunchy” ….besides not cooking it.
Reply
This has become my “are you kidding?” dish. I made it the first time, cut it in half and threw one casserole in the fridge for my bestie and her family. After my boyfriend ate all but my meager portion, I made the mistake of telling him there was another casserole in the fridge… The morning after, there wasn’t. He and his “we’re going to grab a beer” buddies polished it off. I almost hate to make this now because people suddenly start “dropping” by!
Reply
Made this tonight! Really good, even though my cheese sauce didn’t get completely smooth. Next time I’ll let my milk come to a boil before adding my cheese! Thanks for another great recipe! :)
Reply
This had become a regular at our house. We love it. I just had to share it on my own blog. Thanks for a great meal!
Reply
Macaroni Cheese is my favourite ever and this sounded like such an awesome take I had to try it, unfortunately I could not find buffalo cause anywhere :(
To adapt, me and my boyfriend marinated the chicken in a BBQ sauce for an hour and then added some extra to the cheese sauce instrad od buffalo. It was delicious and I am going to continue my hunt for buffalo sauce!!
Reply
Brianna — March 17th, 2013 @ 8:18 pm
Try looking for Frank’s in the condiment section of the store. I know that Costco usually carries it, as well.
Reply
I used all sharp cheddar cheese and it was so gooooood. My brothers lost their minds. To say the least, it was a hit.
Reply