This ice cream is so embarrassing.

Burnt Caramel Bourbon Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Toffee I

You know why? I might have… went through all of the spoons in my utensil drawer tasting it. I wish I was kidding.

I snuck so many freaking tastes of this ice cream that at one point, when I went to sneak another? I realized boom, all the spoons are in the dishwasher. Like, ALL OF THE SPOONS. Like all of the regular teaspoons and the larger whatever-the-heck-they-are spoons. Like all of the spoons from my (OMG I can’t believe I’m even telling you) doubled-up utensil drawer. Yes – two full sets of utensils. The spoons – done. My brain – frozen. My self control – a mess.

Burnt Caramel Bourbon Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Toffee I

I mean, all those little tastes don’t add up or anything. In fact, I probably burned calories getting up and down so often and walking from the drawer to the fridge.

The best part is that I was home alone all week, sooooo yeeeeeah. Awesome. Can’t even blame it on anyone else.

To be frank, this ice cream is whoa. So delicious. It’s so super soft and creamy and gelato-like and dreamy. Dreamy enough that I want to curl up on a big old scoop and take a nap. Oh yes.

Burnt Caramel Bourbon Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Toffee I

I’ve wanted to make burnt caramel ice cream for years, after eating it the last few summers at American Spoon. It’s just so good. And then, with my whole Jeni’s ice cream technique obsession… it’s like it all called out to me. The world would not be right until I made burnt caramel ice cream. With bourbon.

Trust me. The world is right now.

Burnt Caramel Bourbon Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Toffee I

Burnt Caramel Bourbon Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Toffee

5 from 12 votes
Leave a Review »


  • 1 1/2 cups whole milk
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons cornstarch
  • 1/2 cup of your favorite bourbon
  • 1 1/4 cups heavy cream
  • 2 tablespoons light corn syrup
  • 4 tablespoons mascarpone cheese, softened
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 2/3 cup granulated sugar
  • 3/4 cup milk chocolate toffee pieces, like Heath chips or chopped Heath bar


  • Measure out the milk. Take 2 tablespoons of the milk and combine it with the cornstarch to create a slurry, whisking constantly. Set aside. Add the bourbon to the milk.
  • Measure out the heavy cream and add the corn syrup to it. Add the mascarpone to a large bowl and whisk in the salt. Set aside.
  • To make the burnt caramel, I used Jeni’s dry burning technique. You have to keep an eye on the caramel the ENTIRE time! Heat a large (Jeni calls for 4-qt) saucepan over medium heat and add sugar, make sure it is in one layer cover the whole bottom of the pot. Literally watch the sugar until it begins to melt and the outsides turn caramely and melty. Once there is just a small amount of white sugar remaining in the center, use a heat proof spatula and scrape the melted sugar from the sides into the center. Continue to do so until all of the sugar is melted, and stir well. Watch sugar as it begins to bubble and once the edges are bubbly and releasing smoke and the sugar turns a dark amber color, remove from heat. The only way to truly judge it right before it BURN burns is to carefully stand over top and smell/watch. The minute you remove it from the heat, add a few tablespoons of the cream/corn syrup mixture (be careful – it will spit!) and whisk constantly to combine. Slowly add the remaining cream very slowly, whisking constantly.
  • Place the saucepan back over medium heat and add the milk/bourbon mix. Bring the mixture to a rolling boil (for me, this is over medium heat, and it takes a few minutes to achieve. Do NOT remove your eyes from the milk as it can easily bubble up and over, so have a spatula on hand and turn the heat down if necessary, increasing again slowly) and once boiling, boil for 4 minutes. Remore from heat and whisk in the cornstarch slurry, whisking to combine. Place back over heat and cook for another 1-2 minutes, stirring with a spatula until slightly thickened. Gently pour mixture into the large bowl with the mascarpone and whisk to combine.
  • Fill a large bowl with ice and ice water, placing an open gallon-sized ziplock bag in the water, bottom down. Pour the mixture carefully into the bag, the press the air out and seal. Chill for 30-45 minutes. Once chilled, set up your ice cream make according to it’s directions and pour the ice cream in. Churn according to directions. For my kitchenaid, I churned for 20 minutes. 5 minutes before finishing, add in toffee pieces. Once churned, spread in a freezer-safe container and place a piece of plastic wrap on top, pressing against the ice cream. Freeze for 4-6 hours before serving. Note: this ice cream is soft!


[lightly adapted from the salty caramel recipe in Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams]

Did you make this recipe?

Be sure to follow @howsweeteats on instagram and tag #howsweeteats. You can also post a photo of your recipe to our facebook page.
I appreciate you so much!

Burnt Caramel Bourbon Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Toffee I

And yes… I totally ended up continuing those tastings with a fork. I mean forkS.