Chocolate Peanut Butter PEEPS Skillet S’mores!

Let’s see.

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

How can I manipulate you to into throwing your Easter candy in a skillet with chocolate chips and convincing your friends that it’s dessert? Pull up a seat and grab a graham cracker.

Maybe because it takes less than ten minutes?

Because chocolate peanut butter… anything?


Because I really was going to tell you about an insaaaaaane deviled egg today and pushed it back so you could learn about peeps s’mores?

(p.s. be sure to come back tomorrow for a fancy ass deviled egg.)

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

This might be the most trashed up thing I’ve ever done here. Ever.

But! It’s so easy.

It’s so delicious and rich and simple.

It’s so PRETTY. It’s so neon. It’s like an 80s or 90s s’more explosion.

Can this skillet wear legwarmers?

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

Apparently skillet s’mores were a big thing in 2014. I never did it. Never road that train. Never jumped on that bandwagon. Never climbed that mountain.

I was MISSING OUT. So were you.

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

Here’s the thing. We were never a peeps family when I was growing up.

None of us liked peeps.

We never found peeps in our Easter baskets.

In fact, I actually loathed peeps.

Not all the sparkly sugared hot pink and purple bunnies or chicks in the world could change my mind.

(Though I’m pretty sure that back in the day, peeps only came in yellow.)

I think at one point my youngest brother decided that HE liked peeps, so peeps were very slowly introduced in our household.

And then I learned.

I learned that…

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I


chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

I mean, yeah, of course I knew that they were marshmallows, or at least, like, marshmallow-y, but I didn’t realize that they were actually… marshmallows.

I know that it sounds utterly ridiculous.

But it wasn’t until that realization that I started to enjoy peeps as how they should be eaten: in marshmallow-y things.

I don’t love marshmallows on their own (with the exception of homemade ones) but I obviously love them in s’mores, brownies, cookies, s’mores, cake, frosting and s’mores.

Do you think I love s’mores?

I kind of love s’mores.

So while you’ll never find me eating a peep in it’s, uh, purest form, you probably can find me shoving it between two graham crackers with a few bars of chocolate and a big slather of peanut butter.

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

Because, you know, this also means that you can have NEON s’mores.


Hot pink s’mores. Purple s’mores. Blueish-greenish s’mores. Have you ever seen a more fun, more electric s’more?

I’m going to let you in on a secret. Err, not a secret. Just a note. Or something. The peanut butter that I used…?

Are you ready for this?

White chocolate coconut. White chocolate coconut peanut butter. You can obviously use whatever peanut butter you want. Let’s just say that white chocolate peanut butter + chocolate + peeps + s’mores is my own personal heaven. Well, that and maybe Zack Morris or Pacey Witter.

Feeding me the peeps s’mores. Isn’t that everyone’s heaven?

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

Did you make this recipe?

Chocolate Peanut Butter PEEPS Skillet S'mores


3 cups chocolate chips (I use a dark and milk mix)
1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
2 packages of PEEPS marshmallows (obviously more if you want all the colors)
graham crackers for serving


Place the chocolate chips in a 9-inch oven-safe skillet in an even layer. Drop spoonfuls of the peanut butter on top of the chocolate chips. Cover with an layer of peeps – you can stuff them in there! You’ll need around 25 peeps.

Heat the broiler on your oven to HIGH. Place the skillet underneath for 1 to 2 minutes, just until the marshmallows get golden and the chocolate chips are melting. Watch the skillet the entire time. If you find that the chocolate isn’t melted easily, turn the oven to 350 degrees F and let the skillet sit in there for a few minutes so it all melts. Serve immediately – carefully since it’s hot! – with graham crackers for dipping. OMG.

All images and text ©.

Did you make this recipe?

Be sure to follow howsweeteats on instagram and tag #howsweeteats. You can also post a photo of your recipe to the howsweeteats facebook page.

I appreciate you so much!

chocolate peanut butter PEEPS skillet s'mores I

I hope we can get past this.