Can we resolve to do one thing in 2013?

Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons I

Okay, good.

We’re not going to put anything in our mouths that isn’t insanely delicious and wonderful. Yeah yeah – I know how it sounds. But you have to do it.

I think I decided to do this somewhere between the years of 2009 and 2010. At least I’m pretty sure. But whatever, it really was the greatest decision I ever made. The greatest. I make it all count. I can say with sincerity that 98% of the stuff I eat everyday are things I enjoy so, so much. Even to the point of covering with vegetables with, well… something. It’s necessary.

Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons I

So now… tomato soup.

You’re bored already, right? I mean, tomato soup can be boring. Plain. Unexciting. All of those things.

Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons I

The thing about tomato soup? Is that I really don’t care that much for tomato soup. Or at least, I DIDN’T care for tomato soup. Didn’t think I did. You might remember that I’m generally not a fan of tomato sauce. So tomato soup? Eh. It’s sort of like a giant vat of sauce in soup form. Plus, my mom never made tomato soup when we were growing up, and it was due to one very specific reason. I sort of want to tell you but you’re sort of going to die when I do. And since I can’t keep anything from you, here it is: ummmmm, so Mother Lovett used tomato soup… as… tomato sauce. Yeah. Like tomato soup from a can. She put it on noodles. Like spaghetti. Treated it like tomato sauce.

I know. What? This doesn’t even make sense. I didn’t experience this first hand (uh, thank God?) but subliminally I believe it played a part in my tomato sauce hatred and lack thereof tomato soup tastings.

Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons I

I have, however, always enjoyed the idea of tomato soup, especially when paired with grilled cheese and even more so especially because you know I’m that weird person that dips my grilled cheeses in ketchup. I will forever choose ketchup over tomato soup for dipping purposes any day, but since it’s freezing cold and the heart of winter and slightly depressing because the holidays are coming to a close which basically just means there is no longer a constant flow of cookies in the home, soup it is. Plus, soup is satisfying and offers sustenance and all that good stuff. And since I know you’re so tempted to only eat a few lettuce leaves today, it’s just not happening. Hear that? Not. Happening.

I mean… there’s croutons!

Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons I


Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons

Yield: serves 4-6

Total Time: 1.5 hours


2 tablespoons olive oil
2 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 sweet onion, diced
1/2 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon pepper
1/4 teaspoon dried basil
1/4 teaspoon dried oregano
1/4 teaspoon dried thyme
1/4 teaspoon smoked paprika
3 garlic cloves, minced
3 tablespoons tomato paste
2 (28-ounce) cans whole, peeled tomatoes
4 cups low-sodium chicken or vegetable stock
1/3 cup mascarpone cheese
1/3 cup freshly grated havarti cheese

2 cups cubed whole grain bread
3 tablespoons brown butter
2 garlic cloves, minced


Heat a large soup pot oven medium-low heat and add olive oil and butter. Add onions, salt, pepper, seasonings and smoked paprika, then stir well to coat. Cook until onions are soft and translucent, about 5-6 minutes. Stir in garlic and tomato paste, using the back of the spoon well to mash the tomato paste and evenly distribute it throughout the onions. Cook for another 5-6 minutes or so, stirring occasionally, allowing the tomato paste to become golden in spots.

Add in both cans of the tomatoes (with juice) and the stock, bring the mixture to a boil. Reduce to a simmer and let bubble for 1 hour, stirring occasionally. While the mixture is simmering, I occasionally mashed the tomatoes down just to make them easier to blend.

While the soup is cooking, preheat the oven to 375 degrees F. Brown the butter and let it sit for 2-3 minutes, then toss in the minced garlic cloves and stir for 30 seconds. Add bread cubes to a large bowl and pour the garlic/butter mixture over top, tossing well to coat. Place the bread cubes on a baking sheet and bake for 8-10 minutes, tossing once or twice during cooking. If you desire them more golden, bake a little longer - just keep an eye on them.

After the hour is up, very carefully add the mixture to a blender (you will probably have to do this in two parts) and puree until totally smooth. Add back to the pot over low heat. Stir in the mascarpone and havarti, stirring until it's completely melted. Taste and season additionally with salt and pepper if needed. Serve in big bowls with an extra dollop of mascarpone and bunch of croutons on top.

Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons I

Hello comfort in a bowl.

share:    Pin It    

123 Responses to “Creamy Tomato Soup with Brown Butter Garlic Croutons.”

  1. #
    erica — December 9, 2014 @ 2:38 pm

    i dont have a blender or submersion blender…so would you advise using crushed tomatoes instead? this looks so delicious!


    • Brooke — May 27th, 2015 @ 11:19 am

      Erica, maybe even pureed tomatoes? Or a combination of the two?


  2. #
    Betsy @ Spatulas and Buttons — January 4, 2015 @ 10:34 pm

    My husband and I made this tonight and it was divine! Wonderfully flavored soup and perfect for dipping a grilled cheese (we did ours as sandwiches/dipping items on the side, but I need to attempt these brown butter croutons at some point). We’ll definitely make this again. :)



  1. Pingback: The Heart of Life | The Heart of Life

  2. Pingback: New Year New Food | Waiting on Martha

  3. Pingback: Creamy Pasta Verde with Garlic Brown Butter Breadcrumbs | How Sweet It Is

  4. Pingback: web-jaunt… « blah blah birds

  5. Pingback: Green Chile Tomato Soup - The Kitchen Paper

  6. Pingback: Brown Butter Recipes: Pancakes, Ice Cream, Pastas And More (PHOTOS) - Katie's Kitchen Coup

  7. Pingback: it’s that time of year. | the beanstalk

  8. Pingback: soup de jour | the beanstalk

  9. Pingback: Part 2: Fifteen Foods You Should Learn to Cook by 30! | All Honesty

  10. Pingback: 20 Weeks of (different!) Healthier Dinner Ideas | How Sweet It Is

  11. Pingback: 20 Weeks of (different!) Lightened-Up Dinners. | pinmeplease

  12. Pingback: 35 Winter Soup Recipes ~ Perfect to warm up your family!

  13. Pingback: Chicken Parmesan Meatball Soup | Chocolate Moosey

  14. Pingback: Weekly Menus 1/5/13 | Danforth Makery

  15. Pingback: Liquid Comfort

  16. Pingback: Creamy Tomato Soup Shooters with Grilled Cheese Sticks | How Sweet It Is

  17. Pingback: Soup-ed Up! The Best Recipes to Welcome the Cold Weather - FabFitFun

  18. Pingback: Seen on Pinterest: 10 Warm-You-Up Winter Soup Recipes | TDS Home

Leave a Comment

Current ye@r *