Chocolate Cream Pie with Vanilla Whipped Cream.
I’m SO on the chocolate bandwagon right now.
And I needed an excuse to buy these really adorable pink heart paper cups from Target, because it’s Target and where all of my money goes to die, and I couldn’t think of anything better to go with a big fat homemade mocha than chocolate cream pie!
And a new pastel spring scarf. And boots that were on sale. And four new nail polishes, one being super glittery of course. And a random mug and small blue striped bowl that looked cool but will never be used.
Target thought that all of those things would go great with a chocolate cream pie. Target you lie.
Wait. Look at this!
It’s like a graham crust and butter RIVER.
Ooooh but. It’s graham crackers AND oreo cookies – smashed up. Uh. Hello heaven. I am not joking when I say I could probably eat this crust from the bowl with a spoon just like that. Wild child.
I’m practically eating, breathing and sleeping chocolate right now. Been craving it like mad. I’ve resorted to whatever I can find in the house that is full of chocolate and a large tub of peanut butter with a big spoon. Desperate times.
Never in my life have I made a legit chocolate cream pie. Rarely do I ever make pies because, hello, I have zero patience and what requires more patience than a pie? Not much. Maybe croissants.
But you know this and I won’t bore you, other to say that this pie is easy. This pie is slightly time consuming but it’s time spent sitting around while waiting for it to chill. This pie requires no dough!
This pie makes my life. The crust is super thick and wonderful and crunchy. The chocolate layer is super creamy and delicious. I used mostly milk and dark chocolate because my palate is basic even though real food professionals would cringe and use bitter or unsweetened. Um no.
P.S. my chocolate layer loves you.
The whipped cream, which is stupidly easy, might be my favorite part? It is just so light and fluffy – as whipped cream is – but I beat in some vanilla beans and just the sliiiiightest bit of sugar. It’s barely sweet at all, so it really cuts the richness of the other layers.
If there was ever a pie to be pied in the face with, this is it. It’s SO super fluffy.
On a completely random side note: my parents got me a 4.25 quart le creuset pot for Christmas, and it is the perfect size for EVERYTHING. Okay, well by “everything” I mean for about 4 to 6 servings of things or slightly smaller batches of soup. But last week before I made a pot roast for the millionth time, I made this pudding in that pot. BEST IDEA EVER.
And yes that meant that I had a gigantic pot of pudding. Fabulous problem to have.
As a major chocoholic, I feel it is my duty to share other delicious options with you for this upcoming heart holiday. Liiiike these chocolate lovers cupcakes. And this chocolate peanut butter truffle pie. And these buttered popcorn crunch brownies. Or this milk chocolate mousse with coconut whipped cream.
If you really want to get crazy you could make these chocolate chip cookie dough peanut butter cups or this chocolate peanut butter fudge trifle.
And since the way to everyone’s heart is through donuts, please please please fry some real ones – cake with chocolate ganache and sprinkles? Or maybe just these chocolate and potato chip donuts will do. Yep. Probably.
If you’re an anomaly and not so in to chocolate (please tell me HOW?) then these crispy crossiant sundaes are an option (minus the red wine hot fudge?) as are these chocolate chip cookie peanut butter s’mores. Yeah, those will kill you.
This pie might force you into a chocolate obsession though? It won’t be bad.
Chocolate Cream Pie with Vanilla Whipped Cream
- 16 chocolate sandwich cookies, like oreos
- 1 cup graham cracker crumbs
- 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
- 2/3 cup sugar
- 1/4 cup cornstarch
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 4 large egg yolks
- 3 cups whole milk
- 5 ounces dark chocolate, melted
- 2 ounces milk chocolate, melted
- 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
- 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste
vanilla whipped cream
- 2 cups cold heavy cream
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste or 1 vanilla bean, scraped
- 3 tablespoons powdered sugar
- 4 ounces milk chocolate, shaved or grated or curled
- Preheat the oven the 350 degrees F. Add the cookies to a food processor and blend until the cookies are in crumbs. Add the cookies and graham crumbs to a large bowl, stirring to mix. Stir in the melted butter and mix until combined and the ingredients are all wet. Press the crust into a 9-inch pie dish, so it goes up the sides of the dish. Bake for 10 minutes, then let sit and cool while you make the pudding.
- In a saucepan, whisk together the sugar, cornstarch and salt. Add in the egg yolks and whisk until the mixture comes together and is combined. Turn the heat to medium-low and stream in the milk while whisking continuously. Bring the mixture to a bowl, whisking the entire time, then reduce it to a simmer for one minute and continue to whisk. It should thicken. Place a fine mesh strainer over a bowl and pour the filling through the strainer. Whisk in the chocolate, butter and vanilla bean paste until it all comes together and is a thick and delicious chocolate pudding. Cover the surface with a piece of plastic wrap and let cool completely for a few hours.
- Pour the pudding in the pie crust and refrigerate overnight, or for at least 8ish hours. Right before serving, add the whipped cream and chocolate on top.
vanilla whipped cream
- Add the cold heavy cream to the bowl of your electric mixer. Add in the vanilla extract and beans, then with the whisk attachment beat the heavy cream on medium-high speed until stiff peaks form, about 4 to 5 minutes. Add in the sugar and beat for another minute. Top the cream pie with the whipped cream and throw the chocolate shavings on top.
Did you make this recipe?
Be sure to follow @howsweeteats on instagram and tag #howsweeteats. You can also post a photo of your recipe to our facebook page.
I appreciate you so much!
these plates are my dream? yes.
91 Comments on “Chocolate Cream Pie with Vanilla Whipped Cream.”
Omg Making this ASAP.
Made the chocolate lovers cupcakes for work when you first posted them and yeah…..they went over really well. Like really really well. It was comical.
My friend got me the same le crueset Dutch oven…..man are those life changing. I look for excuses to use it. I need more pans like it. Plus the color….whhhyyyy must they come in so many awesome colors???
y’m actually not a big chocolate person, which is funny because the recipe I just posted was a chocolate raspberry tart. Hah.
It’s just a bit too sweet and rich for me on a regular basis. I pretty something slightly sweet and buttery like a sugar cookie. Maybe it’s all the boring (re: healthy) chicken and veggie lunches I force myself to eat during the workweek haha.
This recipe does look worn trying though. It reminds me of all of the tall cakes and pies in the dessert case of diners back home in Maine.
Oh my gosh.. this looks SOOOO good! I a SO trying to avoid stuff like this, but I may not be able to resist!
OMG…this looks AMAZING! Hubby is going to love me…I think I just changed
my mind about what to make him for Valentine’s day. It was going to be a chocolate pudding cake but he has been talking about chocolate pie lately, what great timing!
Pingback: Five Friday Favorites – and a not so favorite… | The Foodie Runner
Omg where can I find a wife that can bake like this!?
Making this as we speak!! The crust came together really easily (used my blender) as did the pudding. It was tricky for me to calculate how much chocolate to add because the brands I bought at Whole Foods come by the pound…but a little online sleuthing did the trick (I think). I used 60% Callebaut and 40% Valrhona Jivara Feves (and 1/3 vanilla bean since I didn’t have paste) – just tasted a little bit of the pudding and OMG. Can’t wait to top it with whipped cream and chocolate shavings tonight! Will report back on how it is…Happy Valentine’s Day!
There are no words than, “Yes, please!” *swoon*
Ughhh this looks so good! My boyfriend loves chocolate cream pie and since our Valentine’s Plans are being snowed out tonight I decided to make this… until I saw that it has to set in the fridge overnight. Cue sad face. :(
Is there any chance it would be okay after like 4 hours in the fridge?
eeeek you can try, but it may still be gooey. maybe if you separate the pudding into like 4 bowls to chill?
Pingback: What's dishing on the blogs: Valentine's Day ideas - Pittsburgh News
Looks like I might be making a chocolate cream pie for the first time very very soon….delicious!
just made this pie for a valentine’s potluck and there wasn’t a crumb left! I did switch it up a little by using mint oreos instead of classic since I’m a sucker for all things mint chocolatey. personal preference would be to make the chocolate ratio more dark, less milk in the pudding for next time, but then again i always prefer dark over milk. overall a stunning and deliciously decadent recipe!
Pingback: Weekly Links 02.15.15 | foodiecology
Pingback: Foodie Favorites - February 18, 2015 - My Bacon-Wrapped Life
Holy Moly girlfriend!!! You have made the pie of my dreams. So creamy….so fluffy!! God that looks good!
Pingback: Pies That Might Be Too Awesome For Their Own Good | WORLD Warotter
Is this 16 oreo cookies worth of cookies or is each half of the sandwich considered a cookie? Also, do you remove the cream?
This looks amazing!
16 WHOLE cookies – and keep the cream!
Pingback: 27 Pies That Couldn’t Be More Fabulous If They TriedThe NEW N!FYmag
I made this with my almost three year old son last week for pi day. He and we LOVED it. The chocolate pudding filling is to die for! My husband said it’s the best chocolate pudding he’s ever had!
Pingback: Pies That Couldn’t Be More Fabulous | WORLD Warotter
Hey Jess! When you begin to make the chocolate pudding, flame should be at medium, correct? Going to make this for my fam for Easter :)
I made this last month! It was soooooo delicious! I’m getting ready to make it for Easter! Hippity Hop!
Pingback: 25 Days of Christmas Crafts: Polymer Clay Cupcake Container
Pingback: What Worked Well – Valentine Edition | Lucky Rhino
Pingback: Thursday Thoughts - Raising Chaos
Pingback: Beyond The Pumpkin: Five Delicious Pumpkin-free Desserts for Fall -
Pingback: 12 Unexpected Thanksgiving Desserts | The Fox & She | Lifestyle Blog
This pie is EVERYTHING! A family favorite!
Pingback: chocolate cream pie with vanilla whipped cream. – 07Recipes
Pingback: Kitchen Trial and Error: my week in food – Kitchen News
Pingback: 27 Pies That Couldn’t Be More Fabulous If They Tried – Groovy Facts
Pingback: 25 Pie Recipes to Serve at Thanksgiving Dinner | Mom Spark - Mom Blogger
Do you melt the dark chocolate before adding it, as you do the milk chocolate? Thanks!! Making this for Thanksgiving!
hi lora! yes you do. sorry about that, just fixed it! :)
Pingback: 20 Recipes to Make for Valentine’s Day! – specialslice.site
Pingback: 18 RECIPES FOR VALENTINE’S DAY – Tfarhad
My nieces wanted chocolate cream pie for Thanksgiving and I tried this one. It was a big hit. I loved that it wasn’t overly sweet and that crust really made it perfection! Thanks for another great recipe!